Riedel et al. / Grain-size evolution in subducted oceanic ...

2. Thermal structure of subducted slabs and phase transformation kinetics

The thermal structure of subducting slabs depends primarily on the rate of subduction and on the age of the subducting oceanic lithosphere and therefore varies greatly for different subduction zones (see, e.g., [13][14]). Minimum predicted slab temperatures can be as low as 500°C at a depth where the olivine-spinel transition sets in in rapidly subducting slabs of old lithosphere. In younger slabs which subduct at relatively low velocity, the minimum temperature at this depth is likely to be much higher than 500°C. The difference between the P-T conditions inside the slab and those outside is one reason that the slab differs in mineralogy from the equilibrium mantle assemblages outside. The conventional picture of the cold slab implies, in addition, that it should also be mechanically stronger than its surrounding, and thus able to sustain and transmit higher stresses to greater depth (therefore acting as a "stress guide").

(32681 bytes)

Fig. 1. Slab geometry used for the numerical model. The slab is considered as a rigid body with thickness L and a fixed length of 1000 km. The penetration angle is 45° (upper surface of the slab at the right side). Isotherms (in Kelvin) are calculated using McKenzie's model [11][12], corrected with the latent heat feedback. The bold line shows the phase equilibrium boundary of olivine and beta-spinel, according to the thermodynamic data of Akaogi et al. [44] Table 1 . (a) vslab=4 cm/yr, L=85 km, Re=59.30. (b) vslab=10 cm/yr, L=85 km, Re=148.25. The metastability region of pure olivine (grey) and the region with mixed olivine-spinel aggregates (dark grey) are shown.

A simple analytical model for the thermal profile of subduction zones is given by McKenzie's solution [11][12] for a slab of finite thickness L subducting into a hotter isothermal mantle of temperature, T0, with constant velocity vslab:

where: Re=rhoCpvslabL/2kappa is the thermal Reynolds number; rho is the density; Cp is the specific heat; kappa is the thermal conductivity of the slab material; and the coordinates (x, z) are parallel to the slab width and length, respectively (Fig. 1 ). According to Eq. 1 , isotherms within the slab are advected downward such that the maximum depth, zmax, reached by any isotherm is proportional to the product of the vertical descent rate (trench-normal convergence rate times the sine of the dip) and the square of plate thickness, zmax~vslab.L2.

The main portion of subducted slabs has an olivine-rich mineralogy in the upper mantle. To simplify the analysis, we assume that a subducting slab is composed of 60% olivine and that this component transforms directly into the spinel phase at a certain depth. At low temperatures, where the transformation of olivine close to the equilibrium pressure is kinetically inhibited, direct transformation to either beta- or gamma-(Mg, Fe)2SiO4 is likely to occur without any change in composition and therefore without long-range diffusion processes [10]. The growth rate of beta or gamma in this case may be described by a kinetic equation of the form:

where: Qa and Va are the activation energy and activation volume for diffusion, respectively; R is the gas constant; Deltaµ is the molar free energy difference between olivine and spinel; and Y0 is a constant.

It has been shown that the alpha->beta and alpha->gamma transition under low (mantle-like) differential stresses of less than about 1 GPa evolves predominantly as a grain-boundary nucleated process; that is, spinel grains nucleate along pre-existing olivine grain boundaries and grow afterwards at the expense of the host olivine [15][16][17]. The appropriate kinetic rate equation for this type of nucleation (compare, e.g., [18]) is:

where: is a pre-exponential constant; k is the Boltzmann constant; is the activation energy for the formation of a critical nucleus that depends on the thermodynamic driving force Deltaµ; and eta is the shape factor accounting for the lowering of , due to the nucleation at pre-existing grain boundaries (see, e.g., [10][19]).

The overall transformation kinetics; that is, the volume fraction of the new phase as a function of time, xi(t), depend on the rates of both nucleation and growth and are affected by the impingement of the growing grains. xi(t) is given by [10][18][20]:

where: Ae is the increase in the extended area fraction of spinel per unit volume (see appendix for details); and vOB is the grain boundary area per unit volume of olivine. The effect of latent heat release is accounted for by including an additional term in Eq. 1 :

where: Fol=0.6 is the olivine content in peridotite; Q is the released heat; and dxi/dt is the increase in transformation degree at depth (x, z') [10][19][21].

In order to obtain the transformed volume fraction of spinel xi(t), Eq. 4 , we solve the ordinary differential equations given in Appendix A , Eq. A4 or Eq. A5 , using a 4th-order Runge-Kutta algorithm [22] along a layer of subducting lithosphere for the local P-T conditions. The effect of latent heat, Eq. 5 , is added as a correction term to T(x, z>z') at each integration step z'->z'+dz' within the slab. We neglect the thermal dissipation of the latent heat in the slab, since it is slow compared with the transformation kinetics for fast subduction [23] and would lead only to minor corrections of the McKenzie temperature profile (adiabatic heating included). Typically, the equations are integrated along the direction of subduction z within 10000 steps; that is, for a slab of 1000 km length the integration step width is 100 m.

Table 1. Thermo-mechanical slab constants and kinetic parameters

Table 1 contains a compilation of the thermodynamic parameters used for the thermo-kinetic model. Note that the kinetic parameter for the non-equilibrium transition of alpha-Mg2SiO4 to beta-phase is still subject to large uncertainties (for respective reviews, see [10][24]).

(14222 bytes)

Fig. 2. P-T phase diagram showing the kinetic phase boundaries for 1% and 99% transformation degree (dashed lines). The thick line shows the phase equilibrium of olivine and beta-spinel, according to the thermodynamic data of Akaogi et al. [44]. The adiabats a-e represent the P-T paths of the coldest portion of a slab (vslab=10 cm/yr) with different thicknesses: (a) L=100 km; (b) L=90 km; (c) L=80 km; (d) L=70 km; (e) L=60 km; (f) boundary condition of the McKenzie model.

The resulting kinetic phase boundaries (1% and 99% transition degree) are shown in Fig. 1 . It can be seen that the thermal structure of a slab is significantly modified by the phase transformation. The non-equilibrium phase boundary of olivine and beta-spinel is advected to greater depth (boundary between the region with metastable olivine (grey) and the two-phase region (dark grey)), and the slab temperature is typically increased by 30-130°C. The P-T paths along the central (coldest) portions of slabs with increasing thicknesses are plotted in Fig. 2 . As emphasized previously [10], the latent heat production causes the transformation to occur by a runaway process, which results in steep thermal gradients around the metastable olivine wedge below 600 km depth [19].


Copyright © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V., Amsterdam. All Rights Reserved.